|
In Skyrim, there's a monastery just below the summit of the Throat of the World, the tallest mountain in the land, and the only way there is on foot. The path is called the Seven Thousand Steps. It starts in a small village called Ivarstead and climbs through pine forest into snow, past stone tablets that tell the story of the place, into a wind that gets worse the higher you go. Somewhere on the upper slopes a frost troll waits for anyone who's underestimated the climb. The name of the monastery is High Hrothgar. At the top live the Greybeards. They are masters of the Voice, the Thu'um, the ancient art of speaking words so charged with power that they move the world. The Voice is spoken in the tongue of dragons, a language almost no one outside the monastery understands. Their own voices are so strong that they almost never use them: one of them, Arngeir, speaks to visitors on behalf of the rest, and the others keep silent. They take no part in the affairs of the land below. Wars come and go, dragons return to the skies, and the Greybeards go on meditating, keeping what they know for the few who make the climb and prove equal to it. It's a game, but the image has stayed with me all week. It describes, more exactly than anything I could have invented, where the deepest knowledge of music engraving has lived for the last thirty years. The MonasteryMasters of the Voice, guarding its secrets on a mountain: you could hardly ask for a better image of the people who know how music should be laid out on a page. Never mind what the notes are, which is the composer's business; the question is how they share out the width of a line, where each line should end, and why a well-engraved page can be read at a glance while a poor one makes the player work for every bar. Those are the real secrets of engraving, and they're mostly invisible. When they're kept, nobody notices anything at all. In the world of notation software, the monastery is LilyPond. Over three decades its makers have assembled the most serious body of engraving knowledge any program possesses, much of it traceable to a handful of academic papers from the 1980s, and built it into a program whose output a great many musicians regard as the nearest thing the field has to a grail. The Seven Thousand Steps are real too. To engrave a piece in LilyPond you don't place notes on a page. You write the music out as text, in a syntax of its own that has to be learned, and hand the whole thing to the program, which works through it in one go and returns finished pages. If you want it to do something differently, you have to speak the monastery's own dragon language, Scheme: a dialect of Lisp, one of the oldest families of programming languages, famous for its thickets of parentheses and impenetrable to most outsiders. Nothing answers you while you work. You write, you wait, you look. I want to be fair to the mountain, because the analogy invites a sneer it doesn't deserve. The steps are no affectation. A program that is given the whole piece at once, and allowed to take its time, can afford to consider every way of laying it out and choose the best. That is exactly what makes its results what they are. The climb is the price of the view. The ValleyMost musicians stay below, and so do most notation programs. Down in the valley a program has to answer as you work: you enter a note and the page changes in front of you. That leaves no time to reconsider the whole piece after every keystroke, so the programs of the valley fill each line as they go, bar by bar, move on when the next bar won't fit, and make the best of whatever they've been left with. Dorico, which takes engraving more seriously than most, works this way, and its developers have said openly why: the careful method was evaluated and found too slow for a program that must respond in real time. Most of the time the results are very good. The rest of the time the engraver finishes the job by hand. So the field has divided along the mountain's flank. Up there, the beautiful results, for those who make the climb. Down here, the convenience, at the cost of a little beauty and a good many afternoons spent correcting. Hardly anyone has said outright that it must be so, but everything has been built as though it were. The knowledge of High Hrothgar, the assumption goes, can only be practised on High Hrothgar. The Path UpUntil a few days ago Ooloi would have been counted among the valley programs, if it was counted at all. It's an interactive program, after all, and that seemed to settle which side of the mountain it belonged to. It doesn't any longer. I've decided that Ooloi will lay out its music by the method Wael Hegazy and John Gourlay described in 1987, in the paper Ulrik Bodén tracked down for me and which I wrote about in the last post. It's the same text LilyPond's teaching grew from, and I'm taking it in its original form: the whole piece considered at once, and the best layout found exactly. ADR-0037, which specifies Ooloi's line breaking, has been revised accordingly, and a new decision record, ADR-0055, now describes how the music is prepared for it. The details are there for anyone who wants them; this post isn't the place. That puts Ooloi in the mountain's lineage. It doesn't put it anywhere near the top. LilyPond has thirty years of practice behind its answers; Ooloi has a decision and a specification. The monastery's knowledge was earned slowly, and I'm a newcomer at its gate with a borrowed book. I do at least speak a dialect of the language. Ooloi is written in Clojure, which is also a Lisp: I speak Dragon. This is perhaps not a coincidence. Down the MountainKnowledge that stays on the mountain is only half useful, though. The real question, the one this whole project keeps returning to, is whether it can be brought down: whether a program that answers as you work can produce what has so far only been produced at the summit. Ooloi takes its name from Octavia Butler's Xenogenesis trilogy. Butler's alien Oankali have three sexes, and the third, the ooloi, can perceive and rearrange the living matter of other creatures. They take genetic material from different lineages and combine it, by instinct, into children that neither parent could ever have produced alone. Nikanj, the ooloi at the heart of the first novel, does exactly this with humans. That's the most honest way I can describe what I'm attempting without a single formula. Ooloi takes the mountain's DNA, its knowledge of how music should be spaced and where lines should break, and combines it with the valley's: a program that answers as you work. If it works, the child will be neither LilyPond made faster nor Dorico made more careful, but something neither lineage could have become by itself. Speed has very little to do with it. Computers have been fast enough for this for decades. What makes the crossing possible is the way Ooloi has been built over the last two years, for reasons that had nothing to do with engraving: by the time layout begins, every bar has been reduced to a handful of numbers that will never change underneath it. The monks' long contemplation of the whole piece becomes a short piece of arithmetic, quick enough to repeat after every note you enter. The last post was about that, under Horace's motto: all the footprints lead one way, and none lead back. (There's also a Dragonborn in the story, a mortal who learns in days what the Greybeards needed lifetimes for. I'll resist that one.) On the MountainThere's another way to read the picture, and it would be dishonest to leave it to the comments. A man working alone for two years on foundations nobody can see yet, refusing to show anything until it's right, measuring himself against a fifty-year horizon: that isn't a portrait of the valley. 'Nun denn, allein!' could have been carved over the door of High Hrothgar. If anyone in this story is living on the mountain at the moment, it's me. The difference, I hope, is the direction of travel. I'm up here so that what gets built can be used down there, by someone who has never heard of Gourlay and never will, and who simply wants a part whose page turns fall in rests. Whether that works isn't something a blog post can settle. None of it is built yet. Everything I can see suggests the architecture will allow it, and the judges will be the printed pages of the great engraving houses, not my hopes for them. 'Come Back in a Year'Almost exactly a year ago, people on various forums were asking when they'd see Ooloi render any notation, and I answered in a short post called 'Where's the Music?'. Not yet, I wrote: foundations first. Come back in a year, and the conversation will be about music by then. The day after, in 'The Lineage: When Ledger Lines Shorten', I wrote that reading LilyPond's essay on engraving had made me realise we came from exactly the same place. I had no idea then how literally that would turn out to be true. Here we are, two weeks early. 'Boxes & Glue', 'Vestigia Nulla Retrorsum' and this post deal with the very heart of engraving: how a line of music shares out its space, and where it should end. Together with ADR-0037 and ADR-0055, they say everything you need to know to understand what Ooloi is aiming for and how it means to get there. The TradeButler's ooloi aren't comfortable creatures. Their trade is seldom asked for, and the humans they trade with don't come through it unchanged. The engraving version is gentler. LilyPond will go on compiling on its mountain and Dorico will go on answering in the valley, exactly as before; nothing is taken from either that doesn't remain where it was. Only the child is new.
Dawn, the first volume of Butler's trilogy, was published in 1987, the same year as Hegazy and Gourlay's paper. That's a coincidence, and I won't pretend otherwise. But Nikanj would have approved.
8 Comments
Magnus Johansson
13/10/2026 19:46:37
"At the top live the Greybeards."
Reply
Ulrik Bodén
13/10/2026 20:37:49
@Magnus, haha, right!
Reply
Magnus Johansson
13/10/2026 21:38:15
Yes, my beard is so grey nowadays that after I have groomed it and look down into the washstand I believe someone has been out collecting dried and crushed reindeer lichen.
Rune Brynsholmen
16/10/2026 20:56:40
Hmm, after this last blogposts I feel like a child in the world of notation engraving. I will shave my grey beard at once :)
Reply
Magnus Johansson
17/10/2026 09:45:52
"I will shave my grey beard at once :)"
Peter Bengtson
20/10/2026 12:51:26
<3
Peter Bengtson
14/10/2026 09:57:53
Welcome to High Hrothgar. You’re right, of course: the grey beards on this mountain belong to Magnus, Ulrik, Rune and me. But the fellowship forming here is wider than its beards, and wider than Sweden: Kim, Andreas, Michael, Renaud and others. People who know music and care how it’s made. I can’t imagine better company for those seven thousand steps.
Reply
Magnus Johansson
14/10/2026 10:12:50
"Let’s start the climb."
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorPeter Bengtson – SearchArchives
November 2026
Categories
All
|
|
|
Ooloi is an open-source desktop music notation system for musicians who need stable, precise engraving and the freedom to notate complex music without workarounds. Scores and parts are handled consistently, remain responsive at scale, and support collaborative work without semantic compromise. They are not tied to proprietary formats or licensing.
Ooloi is currently under development. No release date has been announced.
|
RSS Feed